Religion traditionally has been a major source of institutional support and well-being for Black people in the USA.  However, when juxtaposed with sexuality, religion’s positive effect upon non-heterosexual individuals is questionable.  Research suggests that non-heterosexuals often abandon structured religion for spirituality due to the homonegativity perpetuated through religious institutions.  Although studies have examined religion and spirituality among gays and lesbians, few have examined their roles in the lives of bisexuals.  In this study, we analyzed qualitative interviews of 28 bisexual Black men who resided in New York City.  In addition to church attendance, participants expressed belonging to religious communities through activities (i.e. music ministry).  Despite rejection because of their bisexuality, some participants saw other religious individuals as being accepting of them.  Others discussed church as a place where non-heterosexuals interacted, often for meeting sexual partners.  Participants evoked beliefs in God in coping with adverse life experiences; some linked faith to familial and sexual responsibilities.  Drawing upon relevant literature, we discuss the implications of religion and spirituality for the quality of life of bisexual Black men in the USA.