Courses < > Readings < > Timelines < > Maps < > Notes < > Writing < > Freemasonry
Fall 09 office hours (219 Flint): M & F 10:30-11:30 and by appt (harlandj@ufl.edu)
Imperialism
“the actions and attitudes which create or uphold [empires] – but also less obvious and direct kinds of control or domination by one people or country over others”, e.g. cultural or economic imperialism; (dependency; globalization) [Howe, Empire, A Very Short Introduction]
a system of political control imposed by a metropolitan power on a number of subordinate (peripheral) societies that lay outside the geographic boundaries of the metropolitan nation; the metropolitan power exerts control over its colonies through direct and indirect methods for a variety of commercial, military, strategic, and social reasons [Harland-Jacobs]
Early definitions
the use of national force to secure new markets by
annexing fresh tracts of territory; a political philosophy of
territorial
expansion in search of markets for surplus manufactured goods [Hobson, "Imperialism, 1902"]
the highest stage of capitalism; its basic features include: the creation of monopolies, the emergence of a financial oligarchy that merges bank capital with industrial capital; export of capital become more important than the export of commodities; formation of international monopolies; the territorial division of the world. [Lenin, "Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism"]
the object-less disposition of a state to expansion by force without assigned limits [Schumpeter, "The Sociology of Imperialism"]
Recent definitions
"a sufficient political function of [the] process of integrating
new regions into the expanding economy; its character is largely
decided
by the various and changing relationships between the political and
economic elements of expansion in any particular region and time"
[Robinson and Gallagher, "The
Imperialism of Free Trade," 5-6]
"The distinguishing feature of imperialism is not that it takes a
specific economic, cultural or political form, but that it involved an
incursion, or an attempted incursion, into the sovereignty of another
state. Whether this impulse is resisted or welcomed and whether
it produces costs or benefits are important but separate
questions. What matters for purposes of definition is that one
power has the will, and, if it is to succeed, the capacity to shape the
affairs of another by imposing upon it. The relations established
by imperialism are therefore based upon inequality and not unpon mutual
compromises of the kind which characterise states of interdependence." [Cain and Hopkins, British Imperialism, Innovation and
Expansion, 42-3]
"As an ideology. . . imperialism bundles together different
elements that more or less cohere, though these elements may also
appear
separately or in varying combinations, and with varying degrees of
intensity": advocacy of territorial
expansion by military force; chauvinism based on loyalty to the
existing
Empire; the glorification of the military and of war; racial
superiority of white Europeans; responsibility to import
the light of civilization [Brantlinger, Rule of Darkness, 7-8]
“domination or control of one group over another,” ie,
cultural, religious, or Dollar imperialism; the formation of an empire;
when
one nation extends its dominion over one or several other nations [Baumgart, Imperialism, 1]
an umbrella term covering the whole gamut of relations between a
dominant and a subordinate society; "the effective domination by a
relatively strong state over a weaker people whom it does not control
as it does its home population, or as the effort to secure such
domination" [ Mary Ann Heiss, "The Evolution of
the Imperial Idea and U.S. National Policy," 513, quoting Smith The Pattern of Imperialism (1981),
6, and Fieldhouse Colonialism,
1870-1945 (1981), 1]
“Imperialism is the concept that comprises all forces and
activities contributing to the construction and the maintenance of
transcolonial empires. Imperialism
presupposes the will and ability of an imperial center to define as
imperial
its own national interests. . . Imperialism thus implies not only
colonial
politics, but international politics for which colonies are not just
ends in
themselves, but also pawns in global power games. . . . Imperialism is
planned
and carried out by chanceries, foreign ministries, and ministries of
war,
colonialism by special colonial authorities and ‘men on the spot.’. . .
“Imperialism”is in some respects a more comprehensive concept. ‘Colonialism’ might appear to be one special
manifestation of ‘imperialism’. . ." [Osterhammel, Colonialism, 21-2]
“the late nineteenth/early twentieth century
moment when European empires reached their formal apogee” [Hall, Cultures of Empire, 5]