EUH 3533 Ireland in the British Empire
Fall 2011 (Section 7397)
MWF Per. 3 (9:35-10:25)
Keene Flint 105

Timelines / Maps / Study guide
Bibliography
/ Pronunciation guide

flag

Prof. Jessica Harland-Jacobs

25 Keene-Flint
harlandj@ufl.edu
Office hours: M & W 10:30-11:30
and by appt

Grader: Brenden Kennedy
Office hours: Weds 12:30-1:30

Course description
The primary aim of this course is to examine the place of Ireland in the British Empire and the imperial experiences of the Irish people.  We will cover the main themes of Irish history from the Tudor conquest to the outbreak of the Troubles, all the while being attuned to the broader imperial context.  Ireland was arguably England’s first colony; it was also among the first to assert its independence.  We will explore English methods of conquest and colonization, Irish modes of resistance, and the constantly changing nature of the so-called “Irish question.”  While the English and Scottish colonized the Emerald Isle, the Irish colonized other parts of the world.  Indeed, Irish migration is one of the most salient themes of imperial history.  We will look at the Irish in the Caribbean, North America, Africa, Australia, and New Zealand; we will explore the contribution of Irish soldiers, sailors, officers, merchants, colonial servants, and others to the building of the British Empire.  We will see why the British feared the emergence of “New Irelands” overseas, with United Irishmen, Young Irelanders, Fenians, and Orangemen passionately asserting their opinions in the colonies.  Finally, we will place Irish history in comparative perspective, examining processes and events like colonization, famine, colonial nationalism, partition, and civil war in light of the ways they played out in other parts of the British Empire.


Textbooks [available at Gator Textbooks, 3501 SW 2nd Ave., Suite D (374-4500)]:

Joseph Cohill, Ireland: A Short History (Oxford: Oneworld, 2005)
$19.95 new

J. G. Farrell, The Troubles (NYRB, 2002) $16.95 new

EUH 3533 Coursepack c. $35 [available at Target Copy, 1412 W University Ave (376-3826)]

Selected reading on ARES (electronic reserves)


Attendance policy and expectations
Students are expected to attend class. Late work will not be accepted without penalty.  Please make every effort to apprise the instructor of adverse circumstances that affect your ability to attend class or complete assignments on time. Official documentation is required to excuse an absence and to schedule make-up assignments.  Please keep electronic distractions to a minimum. While you may feel perfectly comfortable multi-tasking in lectures, it is disturbing to the instructor and to those around you. If your behavior proves distracting, you will be asked to leave. History classes are most rewarding when students interact with the texts, each other, and the instructor on a sustained basis. Readings provide the raw material for class discussion, where much of the learning takes place.  Effective class participation is therefore essential. Students can expect a respectful atmosphere in which to express their opinions. In writing papers, be certain to give proper credit whenever you use words, phrases, ideas, arguments, and conclusions drawn from someone else’s work.  Failure to give credit by quoting and/or footnoting is PLAGIARISM and is unacceptable. Please review the University’s honesty policy at http://www.dso.ufl.edu. Please do not hesitate to contact the instructor during the semester if you have any individual concerns or issues that need to be discussed. Students requesting classroom accommodation must first register with the Dean of Students Office.  The Dean of Students Office will provide documentation to the student who must then provide this documentation to the instructor when requesting accommodation.


Assignments and grading
[grade scale]
Papers

Paper 1 [Sept 14]: based on documents, course pack, and outside readings (15%) [guidelines]
Paper 2 [Dec 2]: based on Farrell's The Troubles and limited outside research (15%) [guidelines]


Activities and short assignments
(10%)

18th-c activity report [Sept 23] [guidelines]
Out of Ireland response paper [Oct 26]
Emigrant letters [Nov 2] [guidelines]

optional extra-credit assignment: Historical memory exercise
Choose one person, place, or event we're studying in class. Conduct research to find out how the person, place, or event is commemorated in Ireland. Has commemoration led to any controversies? Write a 2-3-page report. Due any time before the last class (though it's better if you complete it while we are studying your person, place, or event.)



Tests

Map quiz [Aug 31] (5%)


Two tests [Oct 7; Nov 21] (10% each): fill-in-the-blank and document identifications [guidelines]

Exit essay [Dec 16] (15%)
[guidelines]


Participation
(20%)

  • attendance: if you miss a class without notifying the instructor and/or presenting documentation, your overall grade will be deducted by three points.

  • contributions to class discussions: effective class participation entails sharing your impressions of the reading, exploring authors' arguments, offering critiques, and engaging in debates with other students. For each discussion, you will receive points as follow:
  • 3 points: sustained engagement
    2 points: limited contribution
    1 point: in attendance but no contribution; limited contribution but tardy
    0 points: absent
At the end of the semester, I will average your points and assign grades based on the spread (0-3).
Week_1
Note: please read the readings BEFORE class each day
Aug 22
Course introduction
Aug 24
Varieties of Irishness

Reading:
1) Coohill, Preface, Introduction, Ch 1, 1-17 [link]
2) Kishlansky, "How to Read a Document" [CP] [link] and Patrick Rael, "How to Read a Secondary Source" [link] and "Predatory Reading" [CP] [link]
3) Document Set #1 [CP] [link]
Aug 26
Discussion: the practice of Irish history

Reading: Robert Perry, "Revising Irish History: The Northern Ireland conflict and the war of ideas," Journal of European Studies 40, 4 (2010): 329-354
Week_2
 
Aug 29
Tudor conquest

Reading:
1) Coohill, Ch 1, 17-26 [link]
2) Document Set #2 [CP]
Aug 31
Plantation

Map quiz [link]
Sept 2
Plantation, con't.
Week 3

Sept 5
Labor Day -- no class
Sept 7
Stuart Ireland

Reading:
1) Coohill, Ch 1, 17-26
2) David Stevenson, "The Century of Three Kingdoms," History Today 35, 3 (March 1985): 28-33 [CP]
3) Document Set #3 [CP]
Sept 9

Cromwellian conquest/Discussion: Kingdom or colony?

Reading:
1) Document Sets #1-3
2) Stephen Howe, "Contexts and Concepts" and "The Past in the Present," in Ireland and Empire: Colonial Legacies in Irish History and Culture (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002): 7-42 [CP]

Week 4

Sept 12
The Irish abroad in the seventeenth century

Reading: Hilary McD. Beckles, "A 'rioutous and unruly lot': Irish Indentured Servants and Freemen in the English West Indes, 1644-1713," William and Mary Quarterly 47, 4 (Oct 1990): 503-22 [CP]

Sept 14

The Irish abroad con't

Paper 1 due

Sept 16
Restoration and Revolution

Reading:
1) Coohill, Ch 1, 26-38
2) Document Set #4 [CP]
Week 5
 
Sept 19
Ascendancy Ireland

Reading:
1) Bartlett, "Ireland's Long Eighteenth Century," in Ireland: A History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010), 143-63 [ARES]
2) Document Set #5 [CP]


Sept 21
Discussion

Reading:
1) Bartlett, "Ireland's Long Eighteenth Century," 163-74 [ARES]
2) Document Set #5 [CP]
Sept 23

Activity: Addresses and Petitions to the King [guidelines]

Week 6

Sept 26

class cancelled

Sept 28

Golden age or penal era?

Sept 30

Ulster Scots/ Scots Irish

Reading: Patrick Griffin, "'The very scum of mankind': Settlement and adaptation in a new world," in The People with No Name: Ireland's Ulster Scots, America's Scotch Irish, and the Creation of a British Atlantic World, 1689-1764 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2001): 98-124[CP]

Week 7

Oct 3

Ireland and the age of revolution

Reading: Document Set #6 [CP]

Oct 5
Ireland and the age of revolution, cont.
Oct 7

Test 1 [guidelines]

Week 8

Oct 10

The '98 and its aftermath

Reading:
1) Document Set #7 [CP]

Oct 12

Union

Oct 14
the Irish abroad
Week 9

Oct 17

Catholic emancipation and the movement for repeal

Reading:
1) Coohill, Ch 2
2) Document Set #8 [CP]

Oct 19

Famine and exodus

Reading:
1) Coohill, Ch 3
2) Document Set #9 [CP]

Oct 21
Out of Ireland
Week_10

Oct 24 Out of Ireland
Oct 26

Famine and Young Ireland

Reading: Coohill, Ch 4

Out of Ireland response papers: in a 2-3-page, double-spaced paper, let us know what you thought about the film. What did you learn? What were its strengths and weaknesses? How can films help us better understand the past?

Oct 28 The Irish in the empire
Week 11

Oct 31

Nationalism and the land question

Reading: Coohill, Ch 4

Nov 2

Activity: Letters from abroad [guidelines]

Nov 4

Homecoming -- no class

Week 12

Nov 7

Home Rule

Reading:
1) Coohill, Ch 5
2) Daniel Dorrity, "Monkeys in a Menagerie: The Imagery of Unionist Opposition to Home Rule," Eire-Ireland 12, 18 (Fall 1977): 5-22 [CP]

Nov 9

Ireland and India

Discussion: C. A. Bayly, "Ireland, India, and the Empire: 1780-1914," Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 377-97 [CP]

Nov 11

Veterans Day -- no class


Week 13

Nov 14

Nationalism and Unionism

Reading: Coohill, Ch 6

Nov 16

The First World War

Nov 18

The Anglo-Irish War

Reading: Coohill, Ch 7

Week 14

Nov 21

Test 2 [guidelines]

Nov 23

tba

Nov 25
Thanksgiving -- no class
Week 15

Nov 28
Discussion: Farrell
Nov 30

The Making of Two Irelands

Dec 2

Discussion: Farrell

Paper 2 due [guidelines]

Week 16

Dec 5

Reluctant Dominion

Reading:
Kate O'Malley, "Ireland, India and empire: Indo-Irish separatist political links and perceived threats to the British Empire," in Tadhg Foley and Maureen O'Connor, eds, Ireland and India: Colonies, Culture and Empire (Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 2006): 225-32 [CP]

Coohill, Ch 8

Dec 7

Wrap up

Reading: Coohill, Conclusion



Dec 16
Exit essay due by 12:00 [guidelines]