16th Ohrid Summer University, 2013
International Summer School
"Understanding Byzantium in the Balkans: where the East met/parted from the West"
The beginning of the Middle Ages in the Balkans



Florin Curta
University of Florida
August 15-19, 2013
The course deals with one
of the least studied periods in the history of the Balkans, 500 to 900, a
period for which there is dearth of written sources, but a relative
abundance of archaeological material. This crucial period for the
transition between Late
Antiquity and the early Middle Ages in the Balkans is worth a fresh
look, if only to compare the situation in the Peninsula with the general
paradigm of the "transformation of the Roman world," which is now
dominant among historians in Western Europe and North
America (see, for example, Chris Wickham's conspicuous neglect of the
Balkans in his "Framing of the Early Middle Ages"). The purpose of this
course will be to give an overview of the considerable progress made in
archaeological research over the last two decades,
especially in the field of numismatics,
small finds, and the chronology of the Avar
age. Besides a brief discussion of the
problems posed by the few literary sources available (primarily the
Miracles of St. Demetrius and Theophanes Confessor), this course will
take a fresh look at the archaeological evidence pertaining to urban
centers, rural settlements, and burials, as well
as the numismatic evidence (both single finds and hoards). Moreover, the
discussion will involve a re-evaluation of issues of group identity,
primarily that connected to the early Slavs, Bulgars, Serbs, and Croats.
In the light of the historical and archaeological
evidence, the course advances a new interpretation of the spatial
distribution of sites and of their occupation phases that is radically
different from that proposed by most scholars who regard the seventh
century as the period of the "Slavic tide" inundating
the Balkans. Similar attention will be paid to the current debate
surrounding the Croat ethnogenesis. The main theme of the course,
however, is the implementation of the social and economic structures
that marked a radical departure from Antiquity and the beginning
of the medieval period in the history of the Balkans.
August 15: The last century of Roman power (500-620)
Readings:
- William Bowden, "A
new urban élite? Church builders and church building in late-antique Epirus."
In Recent Research in Late-Antique Urbanism, edited by Luke Lavan (Portsmouth: Journal
of Roman Archaeology, 2001), pp. 57-68.
- William Bowden,
"Procopius’ Buildings and the late antique fortifications of Albania."
In New Directions in Albanian Archaeology. Studies Presented to Muzafer
Korkuti, edited by Lorenc Bejko and Richard Hodges (Tirana:
International Centre for Albanian Archaeology, 2006), pp. 223-32.
- Florin
Curta and Andrei Gândilă, "Hoards and hoarding patterns in the early
Byzantine Balkans." Dumbarton Oaks Papers 65-66 (2011-2012):
45-112.
- Archibald W. Dunn,
"Was there a militarisation of the southern Balkans during Late
Antiquity?" In Limes XVIII. Proceedings of the XVIIIth
International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies, edited by Philip
Freeman (Oxford:
Archaeopress, 2002), pp. 705-12.
- Ivan Iordanov, "The
diocese of Thrace
(5th-7th c.) according to the sigillographic data." Archaeologia
Bulgarica 16 (2012), 3: 57-76.
- Olga Karagiorgou,
"LR2: a container for the military annona on the Danubian
border?" In Economy and Exchange in the East
Mediterranean during Late Antiquity. Proceedings of a
Conference at Somerville College, Oxford - 29th May, 1999, edited by
Sean Kingsley and Michael Decker (Oxford:
Oxbow Books, 2001), pp. 129-66.
- Nikolai Rusev,
"Burial rituals in the period of Late Antiquity on the territory of
the province of Second Moesia." In The Lower Danube Roman Limes
(1st-6th c. AD), edited by Liudmil Vagalinski, Nikolai Sharankov and
Sergei Torbatov (Sofia:
National Archaeological Institute and Museum, 2012), pp. 381-404.
- Carolyn S. Snively,
"The new basilica at Golemo Gradište, Konjuh: a sixth century church
in the province
of Dardania."
In Nish i Vizantija, IX.
Simpozium, Nish 3-5. iun 2010. Zbornik
radov, edited by Miša Rakocija (Niš: NKC, 2011), pp. 187-201.
- Jean-Pierre Sodini,
"The transformation of cities in Late Antiquity within the provinces
of Macedonia and Epirus."
In The Transition to Late Antiquity on the Danube and Beyond,
edited by Andrew G. Poulter (Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2007), pp. 311-36.
- Sergei Torbatov,
"Quaestura exercitus: Moesia Secunda and Scythia
under Justinian." Archaeologia Bulgarica 1 (1997), 3: 78-87.
- see a map of the modern Balkans, a map of the northern and central Balkans in the 6th century and a reconstruction of Caričin Grad
August 16: The early Slavs in the Balkans (550-620)
Readings:
- Florin Curta, "The Prague type: a critical approach to
pottery classification." Archaeologia Bulgarica 5 (2001), 1:
73-106.
- Florin Curta, "Female dress and
"Slavic" bow fibulae in Greece." Hesperia
74 (2005), 1: 101-46.
- Florin
Curta, "The early Slavs in the northern and eastern Adriatic region.
A critical approach." Archeologia medievale 37 (2010):
285-306.
- Danijel Dzino,
"’Becoming Slav’, ‘becoming Croat’: new approaches in the research of
identities in post-Roman Illyricum."
Hortus Artium Medievalium 14 (2008): 195-206.
- Vujadin
Ivanišević, "Barbarian settlements in the interior of Illyricum: the case of Caričin Grad." In The
Pontic-Danubian Realm in the Period of the Great Migration, edited by
Vujadin Ivanišević and Michel Kazanski (Paris/Belgrade: Centre de
Recherche d'Histoire et Civilisation de Byzance/Arheološki Institut, 2012),
pp. 57-69.
- Christine
Katsougiannopoulou, "The Slavic bow brooches in Greece
revisited. Some remarks on ethnicity and social status." In Foreigners
in Early Medieval Europe. Thirteen
International Studies in Early Medieval Mobility, edited by Dieter
Quast (Mainz:
Verlag des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums, 2009), pp. 219-31.
- Maciej Salamon,
"Novae in the age of Slav invasions." In Novae. Legionary
Fortress and Late Antique Town, edited by Piotr Dyczek (Warsaw: Center for Research on the Antiquity of
Southeastern Europe, University of Warsaw,
2008), pp. 173-212.
- Franziska E. Schlosser,
"The Slavs in sixth-century Byzantine sources." Byzantinoslavica
61 (2003): 75-82.
- Arkadiusz Sołtysiak,
"The plague endemic and Slavic expansion in the 6th-8th
centuries." Archaeologia Polona 44 (2006): 339-64.
- read also Procopius' description of the Slavs and the Antes, and see examples of the (wrong) scholarly understanding of the Slavic migrations through Eastern Europe and the Balkans
August 17: The short “Dark Ages” (620-680)
Readings:
- Georgi Atanasov, Svetlana
Venelinova and Stanimir Stoichev, "An early medieval graveyard in the
Divdyadovo quarter of Shumen (NE Bulgaria)." Archaeologia Bulgarica 12
(2008), 2: 59-80.
- Csanád Bálint, "Some Avar and Balkan connections
of the Vrap treasure." In From Attila to Charlemagne. Arts of the
Early Medieval Period in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, edited by
Katharine Reynolds Brown, Dafydd Kidd and Charles T. Little (New York:
Metropolitan Museum of Art/Yale University Press, 2000), pp. 180-87.
- Florin Curta, "Byzantium in
Dark-Age Greece (the numismatic evidence in its Balkan context)." Byzantine
and Modern Greek Studies 29 (2005): 113-46.
- Florin Curta, "Were
there any Slavs in seventh-century Macedonia?" Istorija
47 (2012), 1: 61-76.
- Florin Curta,
"Seventh-century fibulae with bent stem in the Balkans." Archaeologia
Bulgarica 17 (2013), 1: 49-70.
- Anna Lampropoulou,
"The presence of Slavs in the western Peloponnese
during the 7th and 8th centuries. New archaeological evidence." In Foreigners
in Early Medieval Europe. Thirteen
International Studies in Early Medieval Mobility, edited by Dieter
Quast (Mainz:
Verlag des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums, 2009), pp. 197-217.
- David Michael Metcalf,
"Monetary recession in the Middle Byzantine period: the numismatic
evidence." Numismatic Chronicle 161 (2001): 111-55.
- Etleva Nallbani, "Urban
and rural mortuary practices in early medieval Illyricum.
Some general considerations." In The Material and the Ideal.
Essays in Medieval Art and Archaeology in Honour of Jean-Michel Spieser,
edited by Anthony Cutler and Arietta Papaconstantiniou (Leiden/Boston:
Brill, 2007), pp. 63-74.
- Mitko B. Panov,
"Reconstructing 7th century Macedonia: some neglected
aspects of the Miracles of St. Demetrius." Istorija 47
(2012), 1: 93-115.
- Dora
Piguet-Panayotova, "The gold
and silver vessels from the Albanian treasure in a new light." Mitteilungen
zur spätantiken Archäologie und byzantinischen Kunstgeschichte 3
(2002): 37-74.
- Efi Ragia, "The
geography of the provincial administration of the Byzantine
empire (ca. 600-1200): I.2. Apothekai of the Balkans
and of the islands of the Aegean Sea
(7th-8th c.)." Byzantinoslavica 59 (2011), 1-2: 86-113.
- Stanislav Stanev and Zarko
Zhdrakov, "The Old
Metropolitan Church in Nessebar/Mesembria after
new epigraphical 7th century evidence." Archaeologia Bulgarica
13 (2009), 1: 87-102.
- Myrto Veikou,
"Byzantine histories, settlement stories: kastra, ‘isles of refuge,’
and ‘unspecified settlements’ as in-between or third spaces. Preliminary
remarks on aspects of Byzantine settlement in Greece." In Oi
byzantines poleis (8os-15os aionas). Prooptikes tes ereunas kai nees
ermeneutikes proseggiseis, edited by Antonia Kiousoupoulou (Rethymno:
Ekdoseis Philosophikes Scholes Panepistemiou Kretes, 2012), pp. 159-206.
- read also the account in the Miracles of St. Demetrius concerning Kuber and the Kermesians
August 18: Bulgaria and the withdrawal
of Avar power
Readings:
- Ivan Bugarski, "Early
mediaeval finds from Veliko Gradište and the appearance of Late Avar belt elements
along the southern bank of the
Middle Danube." Archaeologia Bulgarica 12 (2008), 1:
87-96.
- Florin Curta, "Qagan,
khan or king? Power in early medieval Bulgaria (seventh to ninth
century).") Viator 37 (2006): 1-31.
- Archibald W. Dunn,
"From polis to kastron in southern Macedonia: Amphipolis,
Khrysoupolis, and the Strymon Delta." In Archéologies des espaces agraires méditerranéens au Moyen Age.
Actes du colloque de Murcie (Espagne) tenu du 8 au 12 mai 1992, edited
by Andrés Bazzana (Madrid/Rome: Casa de Velázquez/Ecole Française de Rome,
1999), pp. 399-413.
- Ljubinka Dzhidrova,
"The Komani-Kruje culture: another view. An attempt for the
definition of a culture and an ethnic group as a contribution to the
political administration of the Balkans in the early Middle Ages." In
Papers from the EAA Third Annual Meeting at Ravenna 1997, edited by Mark Pearce
and Maurizio Tosi (Oxford: Archaeopress, 1998), pp. 300-06.
- Uwe Fiedler, "Bulgars
in the Lower Danube region. A survey of
the archaeological evidence and of the state of current research." In
The Other Europe in the Middle Ages.
Avars, Bulgars, Khazars, and Cumans, edited by Florin Curta
(Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2008), pp. 151-236.
- Joachim Henning, "The
metropolis of Pliska or, How large does an early medieval settlement have
to be in order to be called a city?" In Post-Roman Towns, Trade,
and Settlement in Europe and Byzantium,
edited by Joachim Henning (Berlin/New York: De
Gruyter, 2007), pp. 209-40.
- Joachim Henning, Todor
Balabanov, Peter Milo and Daniel Ziemann. "Khan Omurtag's stone
palace of AD 822: a ‘modernized; eighth-century timber fort." In Post-Roman
Towns, Trade, and Settlement in Europe and Byzantium,
edited by Joachim Henning (Berlin/New York: De
Gruyter, 2007), pp. 433-40.
- Solinda Kamani,
"Butrint in the mid-Byzantine period: a new interpretation." Byzantine
and Modern Greek Studies 35 (2011), 2: 115-33.
- Eleonora Kountoura,
"New fortresses and bishoprics in 8th century Thrace."
Revue des études byzantines 55 (1997): 279-89.
- Nicholas Oikonomides,
"A note on the campaign of Staurakios in the Peloponnese
(783/4)." Zbornik radova Vizantološkog Instituta 38
(1999-2000): 61-66.
- Vasilena Petrova,
"The early medieval yellow pottery from Pliska, Bulgaria:
the question of its provenance and the problem of its origin." In Post-Roman
Towns, Trade, and Settlement in Europe and Byzantium,
edited by Joachim Henning (Berlin/New York: De
Gruyter, 2007), pp. 315-40.
- Nikolai Sharankov and
Dimităr Iankov. "A 784 AD inscription of Constantine VI and Irene
from Beroe-Irenopolis (modern Stara Zagora,
south Bulgaria)."
Archaeologia Bulgarica 12 (2008), 1: 77-86.
- Pananos Sophoulis,
"New remarks on the history of Byzantine-Bulgar relations in the late
eighth and early ninth centuries." Byzantinoslavica 68 (2009),
1-2: 119-38.
- Boris A. Todorov,
"Byzantine myths of origin and their functions." Studia
Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana 6 (2008), 2: 64-72.
- Daniel Ziemann,
"Between authoritarianism and consensus: domination and the role of
nobility in the First Bulgarian realm (7th-late 9th century)." Bulgaria
Mediaevalis 2 (2011): 373-97.
- Tibor Živković, "The
date of the creation of the theme of Peloponnese."
Symmeikta 13 (1999): 141-55.
- see a map of the Balkans in the late 7th century, and read also Theophanes' account of the origin of the Bulgars and their migration to the Balkans
August 19: Serbs and Croats (800-900)
Readings:
- Mladen Ančić, "Lombard
and Frankish influences in the formation of the Croatian dukedom." In
L'Adriatico della tarda Antichitŕ all'etŕ carolingia. Atti del convegno
di studio Brescia 11-13 ottobre 2001, edited by Gian Pietro Brogiolo
and Paolo Delogu (Rome:
All'insegna del Giglio, 2005), pp. 213-28.
- Vedran Bileta, "At
the crossroads of Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages - the rise and
fall of the military elite of Byzantine Istria." Annual of
Medieval Studies at the CEU 17 (2011): 100-21.
- Florin Curta, "A note
on trade and trade centers in the eastern and northern Adriatic region
between the eighth and the ninth century." Hortus Artium
Medievalium 16 (2010): 267-76.
- Florin Curta,
"Emperor Heraclius and the conversion of the Croats and the
Serbs." In Medieval Christianitas. Different Regions,
"Faces," Approaches, edited by Cvetelin Stepanov and Georgi
Kazakov (Sofia:
Voenno izdatelstvo, 2010), pp. 121-38.
- John V. A. Fine,
"Croats and Slavs: theories about the historical circumstances of the
Croats' appearance in the Balkans." Byzantinische Forschungen
26 (2000): 205-18.
- Đorđe Janković, "The
Serbs in the Balkans in the light of archaeological findings." In The
Serbian Question in the Balkans, edited by Jovan Ilić, Dušanka
Hadži-Jovančić and Ivanka Grdović (Belgrade: Faculty of Geography,
University of Belgrade, 1995), pp. 125-46.
- Georgios Kardaras,
"The settlement of the Croats and Serbs on the Balkans in the frame
of the Byzantine-Avar conflicts." In Bălgariia, bălgarite i
Evropa. Mit, istoriia, săvremie. IV (Dokladi ot Mezhdunarodna konferenciia
v pamet na prof. d.i.n. Iordan Andreev "Bălgariia, zemia na
blazheni...", V. Tărnovo, 29-31 oktomvri 2009 g.), edited by
Stela Dermendzhieva and Dimităr Dimitrov (Veliko Tărnovo: Universitetsko
izdatelstvo "Sv. sv. Kiril i Metodii", 2011), pp. 91-98.
- Maja Petrinec, "Croatia
between the East and the West--evidence from early medieval graves."
In Rome, Constantinople and
Newly-Converted Europe. Archaeological
and Historical Evidence, edited by Maciej Salamon, Marcin Wołoszyn,
Aleksandr E. Musin and Perica Špehar (Cracow/Leipzig/Rzeszów/Warsaw:
Instytut Archeologii i Etnologii PAN/Leipziger Universitätsverlag, 2012),
pp. 461-74.
- Mario Šlaus, Željko
Tomičić, Ante Uglešić and Radomir Jurić. "Craniometric relationships
among medieval Central European populations: implications for Croat migration
and expansion." Croatian Medical Journal 45 (2004), 4: 434-44.
- Perica Špehar, "By
their fruit you will recognize them - Christianization of Serbia in [the]
Middle Ages." In Tak więc po owocach poznacie ich, edited by
Wojciech Dzieduszycki and Jacek Wrzesiński (Poznań: Stowarzyszenie Naukowe
archeologów polskich. Oddział w Poznaniu, 2010), pp. 203-20.
- Ivan Stevović, "Byzantium, Byzantine Italy and cities on the eastern
coast of the Adriatic: the case of Kotor and Dubrovnik." Zbornik radova
Vizantološkog Instituta 39 (2001): 165-82.
- Trpimir Vedriš,
"’Frankish’ or ‘Byzantine’ saint? The origins of the cult of St.
Martin in Dalmatia." In Sailing
to Byzantium.
Papers from the First and Second Postgraduate Forums in Byzantine Studies,
edited by S. Neocleous (Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2009), pp. 221-49.